Resources Does Natural Capital Accounting Put Nature on Sale?

Published on November 22nd, 2013 | by Derek Markham

3

Does Natural Capital Accounting Put Nature on Sale?

Does Natural Capital Accounting Put Nature on Sale?At first glance, natural capital accounting appears to be a valid step for businesses in the movement toward a more sustainable future, as it’s said to help those businesses gain a better understanding of their environmental impacts, by normalizing them into a monetary unit, which can be measured and tracked.

However, according to Food & Water Watch Europe, natural capital accounting is not the solution that it seems to be, and is “plagued with myriad problems.”

“Governments should not be fooled into thinking that natural capital accounting is a silver bullet to all their environmental and economic problems. Natural capital accounting extends the domain of economic activity and seeks to create economic values where none exist. But, natural capital accounting is really just a desperate attempt to fix a flailing economic model and not an attempt to better manage our fragile environment. Not only does it have serious consequences for the governance of nature and important democratic processes, it is shifting the management of nature into the hands of the same economic actors who are destroying it.” – Wenonah Hauter, Executive Director of Food & Water Europe

One big problem with assigning a pecuniary value to natural resources, and thereby commodifying nature, is that it will eventually transfer environmental protection away from the public and toward private interests.

“Even though the concept of natural capital accounting has been developed and promoted as a policy solution, it is little more than a theory which cannot become reality. The process of converting nature into natural capital and then incorporating it into national accounts and the economy is entirely counterproductive to better environmental management and sustainability.

Many problems exist, from inaccurate information and inaccurate valuation, to the significant loss of values from converting nature into monetary terms. If it actually were possible for natural capital accounting to occur in reality, the subsequent process of commodification required to incorporate nature into the economy creates several more problems. From the idea that ecosystems can be separated into individual products and commodities, to the fact that nature would have to be privatised and property rights would need to be granted in order to become commodities, natural capital accounting in fact becomes a front for the financialisation, privatisation and marketisation of nature.” – Food & Water Europe

For an in-depth look at the issues that Food & Water Europe brings up about natural capital accounting, read or download the full report here: No Accounting for Taste: Natural Capital Accounting and the Financialisation of Nature

[Image: epSos.de]





Tags: , , , , ,


About the Author

lives in southwestern New Mexico and digs bicycles, simple living, organic gardening, sustainable lifestyle design, slacklining, bouldering, and permaculture. He loves good food, with fresh roasted chiles at the top of his list of favorites. Catch up with Derek on Twitter, RebelMouse, Google+, or at his natural parenting site, Natural Papa!



3 Responses to Does Natural Capital Accounting Put Nature on Sale?

  1. Balance3 says:

    It may not be perfect, however to me it provides an access point to engage financial practitioners at all levels in considering that business is dependent on nature instead of outside it. It has great potential to start new conversations, even if the mechanics aren’t perfect yet.

    Nobel Prize winner Muhammad Yunus, founder of the Grameen Bank and his view on capitalism – that many of the problems of the world remain unresolved because capitalism is poorly understood and poorly practiced. He completely rejects the common view, that capitalism is all about the bottom line – he provides capital to the poorest to start businesses that grow local prosperity and employment.

    Natural Capital Accounting is a useful transition mechanism to expanding the business conversation beyond current single-dimension thinking. Far better to start a conversation that the business audience can engage with than simply stand outside and demand “Business – don’t grow!”

    • Very true, and in order to move to a more sustainable economy, it seems to me that embracing the concept of natural capital can provide additional leverage and better decision making, from the supply chain to the consumer.

      • Balance3 says:

        The more options we have to engage with people in business on their terms, the more powerfully we can influence.
        Nobel Prize winner Muhammad Yunus, founder of the Grameen Bank says the issue isn’t capitalism, but the hash people have made of it by interpreting it in the single dimension of ‘bottom line’.
        It will be interesting to hear what comes out of the recent inaugural World Forum on Natural Capitalism

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Back to Top ↑